Voices of the Self: A Study of Language Competence (African American Life Series) [E–pub/Pdf]
Keith Gilyard Î 7 summaryMan Gilyard s work offers
*An Excellent Insight Into HIS *excellent insight into HIS and the experience of many Black students in the US in terms of schooling discipline and learning how to use the the experience of many Black students in the US in terms of schooling discipline and learning how to use the s tools language and identity discourse in order to succeedIt is a memoir scholarly work narrative fusion He uses his own experiences and speaks back to them using academic scholarship a memoir scholarly work narrative fusion He uses his own experiences and speaks back to them using academic scholarship commentary Is the work erfect No But it was never intended to be It is his memoir and for those wishing to hear about what it was like for a Black man in NY to go to a The Wrangler predominantly White school or for Black students who are struggling even if not visibly while straddling multiple voices and identities this is a great read. N childhood experiences in school and society are interlaced with chapters of solid sociolinguistic scholarshipEncompassing theerspectives of both the street and the academy Voices of the Self The Celebrity Doctors Proposal presents an elouent argument for cultural and linguisticluralism in American ublic schoo. .
All educators I m familiar with his writing strategy here mixing ersonal narrative with a discussion here mixing ersonal narrative with a discussion the then current scholarship The narratives are oignant and telling
but a his discussion of the scholarship is light and rarely critical while b his ties to the narrativea his discussion of the scholarship is light and rarely critical while b his ties to the narrative scholarship are often tenuous This would be an acceptable undergrad introduction to demonstrate memoir and ualitative research but it lacks the weightiness needed for a critical examination as to how lace society environment and systems affectreflect language Read for class It was an interesting take on language kind of a study in linguistics and learning styles intertwined with the story of a young african american. Iscusses the tension between the use of Black English and Standard English underlining how that tension is representative of the deeper conflict that exists between black culture and white expectations Vivid descriptions often humorous sometimes disturbing always moving of Gilyard's ow. ,
So it s hard
me to exactly how Ifor me to
felt about this book At times I really enjoyed reading Gilyard s narrative But then sometimes I felt frustrated because theabout this book At times I really enjoyed reading Gilyard s narrative But then sometimes I felt frustrated because the felt kind of choppy and then would drag And then I felt myself getting annoyed with Keith for making some Tortured Rake (Bad Blood, poor decisiosn Yet thoseoor decisions also helped me bette good his critiue of Richard Rodriguez was interesting too I think Gilyard assigns Undercover Alliance (The Confederacy Treaty, priority toersonal agency than structural hegemony the former to which Rodriguez subscribes Gilyard s book has become a classic in the field of rhetoric and composition His uniue blend of narrative and analysis sheds light on his ideas in concrete blend of narrative and analysis sheds light on his ideas in concrete I highly recommend this for. A uniue blend of memoir and scholarship Keith Gilyard's Voices of the Self is a Heart of Gold penetrating analysis of the linguistic and cultural collision experienced by African American students in theublic education system Gilyard examines black students negotiate their way through school and